Police officers and civilians gather around an area enclosed with hanging fabric in a cemetery.

When Law Fails Women: Jirgas, Gender Violence, and the Collapse of International Accountability

Police officers and civilians gather around an area enclosed with hanging fabric in a cemetery.

Commentary —

Just Security: When Law Fails Women: Jirgas, Gender Violence, and the Collapse of International Accountability, authored by HRC alumna Mahwish Moazzam.

Left: Police officers and medical team members gather at a cemetery in Rawalpindi, Pakistan, on July 28, 2025, as they begin the exhumation of a girl’s grave. Authorities order the exhumation to conduct a post-mortem examination and establish the cause of death following allegations that the girl was killed under orders from a jirga, an informal tribal court. Suspects are brought to the site for identification as part of the investigation. The incident has sparked public outcry and renewed scrutiny over the role of illegal jirgas, which continue to operate outside the formal legal system in parts of Pakistan. Human rights activists condemn the extrajudicial process and call for legal reforms and stronger protections for women. The case underscores the ongoing challenges of enforcing state law in rural and semi-urban areas where customary practices still hold sway. Photo by RAJA IMRAN/Middle East Images/AFP via Getty Images.