Architecture of Cruelty: Third Country Removal Agreements and the Second Trump Administration

Author(s)
Linda Gordon, Carolyn Patty Blum, Payson Mayerle, Alexa Koenig, Eric Stover
Publication Date
October 5, 2026
Publication Type
Report
Topic(s)
Open Source Investigations

Summary

Thousands of immigrants across the United States are experiencing the antithesis of their fundamental right to human dignity. This report illuminates the architecture underlying a crucial dimension of this overarching system of cruelty: the removal arrangements that the Trump administration has concluded with approximately three dozen countries to facilitate the transfer of refugees and migrants abroad. Our report identifies and analyzes these documents and — where we could find them — the plans for implementing the agreements. Collectively, our findings constitute the first major analysis of the removal arrangements that have allowed this system to function, one riddled with violations of both domestic and international human rights protections. In creating agreements with countries across the globe, the U.S. is creating a growing coterie of allies, who join in the global project of eviscerating the fundamental rights to asylum and refugee protection. This report examines documents to tease out substantive differences, common themes, and the ways these agreements have changed over time. Our legal analysis is supplemented with data obtained from digital open sources. We have especially paid attention to whether the agreements respect and implement the fundamental international law principle of non-refoulement, which establishes that a person cannot be returned to a country where their life or freedom would be threatened. If the agreements purport to adhere to this principle, then we interrogate whether the receiving countries. have the capacity to ensure its application by processing individual applications in a robust refugee status determination system. We analyze whether the discretion afforded the receiving countries, a component of all of the agreements, has been used or will be used to bypass international obligations.

This report is accompanied by the Architecture of Cruelty Removal Agreements Digital Dashboard.

Key Takeaways

  • The report examines the systematic use of third-country removal agreements by the U.S. government under the Trump administration to deport refugees and migrants to countries outside their home countries. These agreements often result in the violation of international human rights laws, particularly the principle of non-refoulement, which prohibits returning individuals to places where they might face harm.
  • There has been a shift from binding agreements to nonbinding instruments in the deportation process, indicating a move towards greater flexibility and less accountability for the U.S. government. This shift is accompanied by changes in diplomatic language within agreements, moving away from obligations to phrases that suggest voluntary actions, reducing the enforceability of human rights protections for deported individuals.
  • Many receiving countries under these agreements are unable to provide adequate asylum or refugee protections. Some countries lack the legal infrastructure or political will to ensure the rights of third-country nationals, leading to situations where deported individuals can face onward removal to their home countries or other regions where they face risk, violating the initial assurances made in removal agreements.
  • There is significant financial leverage involved in these agreements, with the U.S. government providing financial incentives to receiving countries to accept deportees. This funding is often tied to broader foreign policy goals, mking the agreements a tool of diplomacy rather than purely humanitarian or refugee protection mechanisms.
  • TDeportation policies executed under the Trump administration are characterized by a lack of transparency and an erosion of due process in the immigration system. The violent and secretive nature of these operations has led to significant human rights abuses against those being deported.

Q&As

What is the focus of this report by the Human Rights Center?
The focus of the report is on the Trump Administration's third country removal agreements and their impact on immigrant communities, with particular attention to the use of removal arrangements with other countries to facilitate the transfer of refugees and migrants from the United States.
What are third country removal agreements?
Third country removal agreements are arrangements between the United States and another country that allow for the transfer of refugees and migrants from the United States to the third country. These agreements often lack transparency and may circumvent international legal obligations designed to protect migrants from persecution.
How does the Trump Administration utilize these agreements according to the report?
The Trump Administration has used third country removal agreements as a tool for mass deportation, often bypassing due process and existing legal protections for migrants. These agreements are used to quickly remove individuals from the U.S. without properly assessing their claims for protection from persecution or torture.
What are some documented consequences of the third country removal agreements?
Consequences of these agreements include violations of international law, such as chain refoulement, where individuals are transferred to countries where they face persecution or torture. Additionally, migrants are often not provided clear information or protection mechanisms, leading to situations where they endure further harm or imprisonment in the receiving country.
What has been the response of the international community to these agreements?
The international community, including the UN and human rights organizations, has expressed concern over the lack of legal protections and the potential violations of international obligations by countries involved in these agreements. Press statements have been issued urging countries to uphold human rights standards and prevent the forced return of individuals to countries where they may face harm.

Suggested Citation

Gordon, L., Blum, C., Mayerle, P., Koenig, A., & Stover, E. (2026)
Architecture of Cruelty: Third Country Removal Agreements and the Second Trump Administration.
Human Rights Center, UC Berkeley. https://humanrights.berkeley.edu/publications/architecture-of-cruelty/