Finding the Signal in the Noise: International Criminal Evidence and Procedure in the Digital Age

Author(s)
Lindsay Freeman, Raquel Vazquez Llorente
Publication Date
March 1, 2021
Publication Type
Journal Article
Topic(s)
International Criminal Law, International Humanitarian Law, Open Source Investigations, Technology

Summary

The constituent documents of the International Criminal Court (ICC) were formulated in the 1990s, at a time when the internet was still relatively new to most of society. In the four years between the signing of the Rome Statute in 1998 and its entry into force in 2002, there was a surge in technological development. The replacement of dial-up connections by home broadband and wireless internet, the commercial launch of 3G, and the introduction of camera phones all took place during that period, followed only a few years later by the founding of Google, YouTube and Facebook. This trend has only continued. Advanced technologies have changed the way in which societies create information and share it, generating an ever-growing volume of data. The availability and accessibility to new sources of information open up opportunities for international criminal investigators, but the task of using them effectively is not without its challenges. Recent cases before the ICC indicate that digital evidence will play an increasingly central role in investigations and prosecutions. In national jurisdictions, digital evidence is now introduced in the majority of criminal cases, and there have been significant reforms in domestic statutes on evidentiary and procedural rules from admissibility to e-discovery. However, such reforms have not yet materialized at the ICC. This article assesses whether the Rome Statute and Rules of Procedure and Evidence, and their current interpretation, remain effective and appropriate in the face of technological change. The authors examine the emerging challenges related to the use and handling of digital evidence, as well as the unique nature of the internet and other dissemination channels. By drawing attention to the main issues with the existing rules and practices, and raising unresolved questions, the authors highlight the importance of reassessing rules based on obsolete assumptions and expectations as we move towards the future.

Key Takeaways

  • The International Criminal Court (ICC) is facing significant challenges due to the advancement of digital technologies and the abundance of digital evidence, which were not foreseen when the Rome Statute and other foundational documents were formulated in the late 1990s.
  • Digital evidence presents unique challenges due to its volume, the ease with which it can be manipulated or erased, and the complex legal and technical issues it introduces. Investigators and courts need clear guidelines and improved tools to effectively collect and assess digital evidence.
  • There is a growing need for reform within the ICC’s procedural framework and practices to address the challenges introduced by digital evidence. This includes updating interpretations of existing rules, creating guidelines for online investigations, and allowing for early digital preservation of potential evidence.
  • The ICC needs to improve its investment in IT infrastructure and regular updates to its E-court Protocol to handle the influx of digital evidence more efficiently. This includes collaboration with academia and the private sector to leverage the latest technological advancements such as machine learning and artificial intelligence.
  • The court must consider the privacy implications of digital evidence and the challenges of ensuring fair trial procedures in an age of vast and often intrusive data. This includes making early admissibility decisions to avoid excessive clutter in evidentiary records.
  • There is a pressing need for education and training for all parties involved in criminal investigations and trials, from first responders to judges, to enhance their understanding of digital evidence and improve the judicial process.

Suggested Citation

Freeman, L., & Llorente, R. (2021)
Finding the Signal in the Noise: International Criminal Evidence and Procedure in the Digital Age.
Human Rights Center, UC Berkeley. https://humanrights.berkeley.edu/publications/finding-the-signal-in-the-noise-international-criminal-evidence-and-procedure-in-the-digital-age/